Saturday, May 10, 2025

Crying at the Movies

This is my entry in the Classic Movie Blog Association Cry Me A River Tearjerkers Blogathon. Click HERE for more weepies - and don't forget to bring a hanky.

So, here's my story.

I was walking down a dark street of the soul when James Cagney grabbed my hand and pulled me into the light. He did this not once, at least twice, and maybe a few more times that I can’t specifically recall.

The last time this happened was a month or so ago at a screening of "Ragtime." Of course, it wasn’t the real and long-dead James Cagney. No, it was the glittering, electric, oh so alluring silver screen shadow Cagney. The one that never dies.

The first time this happened was when I was 12. Oh gosh, I loved that adolescent girl, standing on the brink, thinking and believing everything she desired was possible. Time was an unending runway. Like a cattle brand, those first and early passions that rise past mere wants were imprinted in me. And even now, after the slow, sometimes dreary, sometimes wonderful blink of an eye that passes for life I can rub my figurative finger over my true self and still feel the faint impressions of that brand.

Funny. We seem to spend the first part of our life developing an armor against hurt and then the remainder peeling away that armor in search of our authentic emotional self. This leaves a tender spot, and as a consequence, we cry a lot. And not just over sad things. Which brings me to this little clip, the closing credits of 1984's "All of Me."

Cute, right? Yet, every time I see it, I start to sob real tears. But all tears are not an expression of sorrow or hurt. At this point in my life, those emotions bring a frown and something in my chest that feels like heartbreak. Now it is joy and beauty that elicit those tears. Steve Martin and Lily Tomlin are pure joy, happiness, unbridled silliness -a great and beautiful thing. 

I've been writing about movies for quite some time now. I'm not much of a reviewer. I like to explore the emotional experience of watching a particular film, which brings me to "Ragtime." Cagney was 82 at the time that movie and his role was small, yet the sight of him made me cry. I cried not because he was so changed from the way he looked in his prime. No, I cried because in his face on the screen I saw all of the history and stories I had written on my heart tangled up with his cinematic history and how grand a ruin he appeared and how raw and real I felt in my seat, in the dark, deep in rapture, crying and filled with joy.


20 comments:

Realweegiemidget Reviews said...

I really loved your post, and so want to see this one again now.

Christian Esquevin said...

Great juxtaposition of All of Me with your fond memories of Jimmy Cagney in youth and old age - there's much there to bring out the tears in us as we see those films through the lens of time and of our own life.

carygrantwonteatyou.com said...

What an enchanting post. I won't lie--I got a little teary reading it. And how right you are that "We seem to spend the first part of our life developing an armor against hurt and then the remainder peeling away that armor in search of our authentic emotional self." I loved All of Me as a kid and love it still.

FlickChick said...

Steve and Lily are just so good - really made me appreciate Steve as a real life genuine movie star.

FlickChick said...

Thank you, Christian. I struggle to put into words the relationship between our own emotions and what we see on the screen. So complex - and so wonderful.

FlickChick said...

I confess, I made myself tear up a little, too.

Karen said...

I loved your post, and I completely understood why you cry watching this scene -- I know just what you meant. I've never seen this movie -- the closest I came was the TCM film fest a few years back, when Lily Tomlin was scheduled to do the introduction for All of Me at Graumann's Chinese Theater. I didn't care one way or the other about seeing the movie -- I just wanted to see Lily, and as I stood in line, the word began to spread that she wasn't coming. Once it was confirmed, I got out of line, wound up seeing Queen Bee, and never saw All of Me. I want to remedy that now, after reading your post -- if for no other reason than to give me a foundation for that sweet scene under the credits!

FlickChick said...

Thank you, Karen. I was there that year and was bummed that Lily blew off the film, but made a point to see it because it is so good. Give it a try.

Jocelyn said...

Such a moving post...putting all your emotion out there, wow! As film fans it is so great to have an outlet for exploring such powerful emotions. Your love for Cagney resonated with me, too, as he has so many character shades--in all his roles you can't NOT watch him. I'm not sure the last time I watched Ragtime, but I definitely want to revisit it now. Thank you!

FlickChick said...

Thank you, Jocelyn. At this stage of my life, I want to cut through my many "poses" and get to the heart of the emotional matter, if I can.

said...

That was SO beautiful. I'm not much of a crier, but we do need to pay attention to not let our armor numb our feelings.
Thanks for the kind comment!
Le

Jacqueline T. Lynch said...

Lovely. I find it's unexpected moments like this, rather than being bludgeoned with a "tearjerker" theme all through a movie that really brings on the tears.

FlickChick said...

Thank you, Le. You are so very right. And it takes longer to peel it away than to build it.

FlickChick said...

Jacqueline, isn't that the truth? So much more delightful when your emotions aren't being manipulated (no matter how skillfully).

Toni Ruberto said...

What a lovely story - I had to read it twice because it touched me so deeply. You have a beautiful writing style and I loved that you bared your emotions to us. It's a wonderful tribute to James Cagney, as well as to "All of Me" which I'm going to watch again as soon as I can.
-Toni R.

Silver Screenings said...

I love, absolutely love, this piece. Your writing is lyrical and moving, and it expresses much of what I also feel about movies. Thank you for sharing this with all of us.

FlickChick said...

Thank you so much, Toni. Every time I write about a film that moved me it feels like a love letter.

FlickChick said...

Thanks for stopping by, Vintage Nerd. All of Me is such a fun film and Steve and Lily are just perfect.

FlickChick said...

Thank you, Ruth. I love writing about the things Iove.

Rebecca Deniston said...

Fabulous piece. It's definitely an emotional experience to see actors as they were, and then as they are in the present, or what used to be the present, and Cagney's charisma was amazing. I remember Michael J. Fox talking about meeting Cagney and he said that even in his old age the man still had a very firm handshake.