Miriam as Julia Hurstwood: she's not taking a philandering husband laying down |
See this film if you can for one of Laurence Olivier’s greatest, most romantic screen performances. Based on Theodore Dreiser’s novel, “Sister Carrie”, published in 1900, William Wyler’s film version, “Carrie,” tells the story of a dumb, young lovely (Jennifer Jones) who leaves the farm for the big city (Chicago) to live with her sister. Sis lives in a cramped apartment with her husband and children and makes it clear to Carrie that she needs to get off her pretty little behind and earn her keep. Carrie soon decides factory work is not for her and allows herself to be picked up by flirty traveling salesman, Charles Drouet (played with oily charm by Eddie Albert). The next thing you know they are playing house and Carrie has new duds and a kitten. Charlie is often gone, so Carrie has lots of time on her hands. She takes an interest in amateur theatre and George Hurstwood (Laurence Olivier), the manager of an upscale watering hole.
Carrie loves the lifestyle George gives her - at first |
George is everything Charlie is not: he is refined and cultured. Unfortunately, he is also married. And not just a little married, but a lot married – to the formidable Julia Hurstwood. She is presented as such a bitch that you really do feel sorry for George. Sorry enough to forgive him stealing money, lying to Carrie to whisk her away to New York, marrying her while still married to Julia, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
George tries to hang on to Carrie, but he knows his star is falling and hers is rising |
Olivier is the whole show
here. His descent into homeless despair while Carrie's star rises is
heartbreaking. He risked all for love and ended up empty-handed. Carrie feels
remorse, but loves the materialism of the new century. In that, she is not
unlike Julia Hurstwood. I'll bet Julia was not such a bitch so very long ago,
but when George tells her he means to have some happiness she says no
- not if it hurts her. Sir Larry is at his best, but Miriam is
not to be overshadowed. When she steams into New York to find George and Carrie
living together she looks her younger rival up and down and drawls, ice cubes
laced with molasses, "I thought you'd be prettier." Well, she kept
the money and got rid of the future bum. Good going, Julia. Like they say, if
she were a man she'd be ruthless and strong, but as a woman, she's just a bitch.
All for love: his old life is gone and so is Carrie |
Check out Julia giving George what for:
I also found this very touching video someone made about George and Carrie's romance.
16 comments:
Carrie is one of my favorite Olivier movies. A great ensemble cast too. I love Hopkins and Olivier together. It is such a sad movie, but I have watched it many times.
"Heartbreaking" is definitely the word for Hurstwood and Olivier's work here. It's a movie filled with dramatics I admire, but one I find difficult to revisit often. It breaks me up. Miriam certainly did fine things with William Wyler.
Thank you, Panavia - it is a very sad film, but Olivier is so romantic, it breaks my heart.
Hi CW - yes, Miriam had to fight for some good scenes here in a pretty nasty role, but Wyler gives her the chance to really show the hurt under the venom.
This film looks like it would be SO moving! I was starting to get a little verklempt just watching the clips you posted!
I can only imagine Miriam holding her own against Lawrence Olivier, and I cannot wait to see this film!
Thanks for participating in the blogathon with this unknown (to me) gem!
Hopkins is so steely and cold here, but she does give you an insight into her character's position: as a married woman in 1900, she's dependent on her husband and needs to fight to make sure she's taken care of. I liked how she played the role without compromise, letting you understand her character's point of view. I think Hopkins herself was a fighter and no doubt understood where Mrs Hurstwood was coming from.
Count me in as another one who loves this film (and Dreiser's novel too). I'm a big fan of Olivier so it breaks my heart too and I totally agree it is one of his greatest performances. Jennifer Jones is also good, but it's all about Olivier! I was surprised to see Hopkins in such a cold, nasty role, but, as you say, she really does make the character formidable. Judy
Well, FlickChick you've done it again - piqued my interest in a movie I've passed over numerous times! I love how you start off talking about Miriam but most of the post seems to be about Olivier. lol
Miriam played the nasty one several times (anyone remember OLD ACQUAINTANCE?) but my favorite of such roles is THE MATING SEASON with Gene Tierney. What does she do in those parts to make you want to watch what she does? Must be that thing they call Star power ....
Off to see when my favorite channel will be showing CARRIE!
Thanks for hosting, Ruth - this great lady deserves more love.
Yes Grandoldmovies - I totally agree. Miriam's Julia is understandable. Romantic love is selfish, and Julia wasn't going to be a victim.
Judy - Olivier's autumnal grasp at romance is so heartfelt. I agree Jennifer Jones is just okay, but Carrie really is a bit of a twit here.
Elizabeth - well, Miriam's role was small here - it really was all about Larry. But she got off some good scenes.
Love Hopkins' life philosophy in this film, which is one of my favorite Olivier movies. I second Caftan Woman's comment about the 'dramatics' but it's not an easy watch. I do love the costume in the first still you posted - such a frothy affair but she wears it so well!
You are the third blogger who says wonderful things about this movie that is only getting higher in my watchlist. The cast is just marvelous!
Thanks for the kind comment!
Kisses!
Le
Hi Girls - it is hard to watch because it is so sad. Good thing Miriam was around to inject some venom.
Le - I hope you do get to watch someday!
Post a Comment